- Open Access
Delayed double reading of whole blood clotting test (WBCT) results at 20 and 30 minutes enhances diagnosis and treatment of viper envenomation
Journal of Venomous Animals and Toxins including Tropical Diseasesvolume 24, Article number: 14 (2018)
The whole blood clotting test (WBCT) is a simple test of coagulation that is often used in the assessment, diagnosis, and therapeutic monitoring of snakebite patients in sub-Saharan Africa. WBCT requires only a clean glass tube and several milliliters of venous blood and is ideal for use in poorly equipped health centers throughout the rural areas where 95% of snakebites occur. However, questions surrounding the accuracy and reliability of the test remain unanswered due to variations in testing conditions and a lack of comparative research with which to validate them. This is the first study to evaluate WBCT results at both 20-min (WBCT20) and 30-min (WBCT30) reading times in the same group of snakebite patients.
In order to define the best reading time, the authors compared the results of serial WBCT evaluation at both 20 and 30 min after collection in 23 patients treated for snake envenomation in Bembèrèkè, northern Benin.
WBCT results were identical at both reading times in patients without coagulopathy or when coagulation was restored permanently following a single dose of antivenom. Out of 17 patients with coagulopathy, 14 showed discrepancies between WBCT20 and WBCT30 results in at least one pair of serial evaluations. These could be completely contradictory results (e.g. normal clot at WBCT20 and no clot at WBCT30) or a marked difference in the quality of the clot (e.g. no clotting activity at WBCT20 and an unstable partial clot at WBCT30). WBCT discrepancies were encountered most frequently in three situations: initial normalization of hemostasis following antivenom therapy, detection of a secondary resumption of coagulopathy, or final restoration of hemostasis after a secondary resumption had occurred.
This study suggests that the WBCT is robust and that a sequential reading should improve the diagnosis and monitoring of venom-induced coagulopathies. It also indicates the possibility of discrepancies in the sensitivity of WBCT20 and WBCT30 for detecting the resolution or reoccurrence of coagulopathy and identifies how these findings, if confirmed, may be used to increase the efficacy and efficiency of antivenom treatment in the field.
In developing countries, particularly in sub-Saharan Africa, most envenomations occur in rural areas and are managed in peripheral health centers lacking the capability to perform automated laboratory tests for diagnosis or monitoring of envenomed patients [1, 2]. Venom-induced consumption coagulopathies (VICC) are present in more than two-thirds of African snake envenomations . When used correctly, the whole blood clotting test (WBCT) is a simple, effective, affordable bedside examination that provides valuable information during initial assessment and ongoing management of snakebite patients throughout the course of treatment [4,5,6,7]. Use of the WBCT for detecting VICC in snakebite patients was standardized by Sano-Martins et al. . It requires collection of a small amount of venous blood (about 2 mL) in a dry and clean glass tube to evaluate the coagulation time by simple direct observation of clot formation and stability 20 min after collection. Several field studies have confirmed that the WBCT was sufficiently sensitive and specific to be of clinical value [4, 5, 9,10,11]. It is a comprehensive blood test to diagnose and monitor coagulopathy in patients bitten by most viper species, which is valid throughout the world. It is also useful for diagnosis of coagulopathy in patients bitten by dangerous colubrids and many of the elapid species found in Australasia. The WBCT is particularly useful when the symptoms are mild or before the onset of clinical hemorrhagic syndrome [5, 6, 9, 12]. In addition, the WBCT is an important criterion for evaluating the efficacy of antivenom therapy [3, 9, 13, 14].
The test should be carried out in a clean, dry, glass tube completely free of detergent. Deviations from this protocol such as the use of poorly rinsed glassware or any non-glass tubes can alter the outcome of the test and lead to inaccurate interpretation . In addition, there have been reported contradictory results regarding accuracy of the WBCT under varying conditions [6, 16, 17]. It is generally recommended to observe the clot at the 20th minute (WBCT20), but many studies have reported a delay in reading until the 30th minute (WBCT30). This likely results from the many tasks that must be accomplished by clinicians during initial assessment and stabilization of the patient, which oftentimes takes place in overcrowded and understaffed rural health centers . This reading delay is likely to affect the test results but has never been evaluated .
In order to see how the WBCT performs in a realistically challenging clinical setting, we performed a preliminary study in 23 snakebite patients treated in rural Beninese hospital in order to compare the results of WBCT interpretation at 20 and 30 min and assess the reliability of the measurements taken at different time points from the same group of patients.
Twenty-three snakebite patients were evaluated using both WBCT20 and WBCT30 readings at the Hôpital Evangelique de Bembèrèkè in Bembèrèkè, northern Benin, between late June and early October 2012. In order to accurately reflect the challenging circumstances in which WBCT testing is used in rural Africa, all patients who were evaluated using both WBCT20 and WBCT30 throughout the course of care were included in this study regardless of treatment delay and severity of envenomation. Assessment, diagnosis, treatment, and clinical management of all patients from intake to discharge was performed by one of the authors (JB) to ensure homogeneity of testing methods and results. Snake identifications were made by JB based on examination of the snake or description of the snake by the patient or family in conjunction with the clinical syndrome of envenomation. Clinical examination and WBCT interpretation were performed during the initial assessment at hour 0 (H0) in all patients prior to administration of the polyvalent antivenom (Antivipmyn® Africa, Bioclon, Mexico). The WBCT was repeated during serial reexaminations at H3, H6, H12, H24 and every 24 h thereafter until permanent restoration of blood clotting (no hemorrhage or coagulopathy for more than 48 h) and complete resolution of the envenomation had been achieved.
The WBCT was always evaluated twice in all patients: first in the 20th minute after collection and again at the 30th minute (Fig. 1). The following grading scale was used for WBCT interpretation: Grade 0: normal coagulation (solid, stable clot); Grade 1: abnormal coagulation (unstable or friable clot that disintegrates rapidly upon inversion of the test tube); Grade 2: no coagulation (Table 1).
All tests were timed to ensure that the readings occurred precisely at the 20th and 30th minute after collection. Most tests were performed using a separate tube for each reading time, particularly those performed in the first 24 h, but we observed no discrepancies between the two methods and in some cases it was easier to perform the test in a single tube due to the circumstances (multiple critically ill patients at one time, quantity of blood collected, etc.). When a single tube was used, it was tipped at both 20 and 30 min without disturbing it between readings. When two tubes were used, the WBCT20 tube was tipped a second time at 30 min and invariably yielded the same results as the WBCT30 tube which was only tipped at 30 min. WBCT samples were retained for observation in the glass tube for at least 24 h before disposal. Ambient temperature in the wards where tests were performed typically ranged from 24 to 27 °C.
It is widely accepted that the test should be conducted in a clean, dry, glass tube free of any contaminants such as soap residue. However, there are no tubes produced specifically for the WBCT and it is generally performed using whatever clean glass vessels (test tubes, medication vials or ampoules, etc.) are available in the clinic at that time. In order to ensure that the results were both accurate and applicable under realistic conditions, we conducted an informal test at the beginning of the study using various appropriate-sized containers that were available at the hospital.
Blood samples were collected from five healthy volunteers and evaluated in:
disposable BGL Sysmet 10 mL plain glass red top vacutubes, 13 × 100 mm;
standard disposable plastic syringes, between 3 and 10 mL;
screw cap clear glass medication vials, approximately 19 × 73 mm;
5-mL clear glass serum bottles, 23 × 47 mm; and
an assortment of reusable 10 mL plain glass test tubes, approximately 13 × 100 mm, that were maintained by clinical laboratory personnel for the WBCT and a number of other blood tests.
Blood failed to clot normally in plastic syringes at both reading times (Fig. 2) and results in the BGL Sysmet vacutubes were inconsistent. The glassware from groups (c), (d) and (e) yielded accurate results in all donors. The clots in these tubes remained intact when disposed of 3 h later, indicating the absence of any physiological hyperfibrinolysis in the control group. The five donors consisted of two males and three females between 21 and 30 years of age. They were all visiting healthcare workers from Europe, Canada, and the United States with known medical histories and without medications or conditions that could interfere with normal coagulation. All WBCT samples in the formal study were evaluated using the plain glass 10-mL test tubes from group (e) and all tubes were carefully examined by JB prior to use to ensure that they were free of any scratches, residues, or other imperfections that could potentially interfere with the test. Pre-checked tubes were placed in plastic bags and set aside in a designated snakebite kit to ensure they would not be exchanged or contaminated prior to use. When necessary, tests were repeated in fresh tubes to confirm results that were inconsistent with the clinical picture at the time.
Blood samples for WBCT testing were drawn from the peripheral IV catheter during initial cannulation at H0, through venipuncture in the opposite arm during the first 24 h after an antivenom treatment, and drawn by either method thereafter. Venipuncture was used whenever possible and comprised the majority of samples. In all occasions when it was necessary to obtain samples from existing peripheral IV catheters, a 2 mL waste draw was performed first to ensure collection of an undiluted sample. Numerous studies have validated this as an acceptable alternative to venipuncture with no statistically significant difference in hematocrit, hemoglobin, CBC, PT/INR, aPTT and other parameters between the two methods [18,19,20,21].
Antivipmyn® Africa (AA) dosage was determined by the severity of the individual envenomation, which was assessed using a clinical gradation scale of local and systemic findings given elsewhere as well as hematocrit testing by centrifugation to detect anemia [3, 9, 10, 13]. The extent of edema and bleeding was scored according to the chart detailed below (Table 2). Patients with incoagulable blood (defined by abnormal WBCT results at 20 and/or 30 min) and/or abnormal atraumatic bleeding (as described in Table 2) at H0 received an initial antivenom dose of two vials in 10 mL of sterile water administered by direct intravenous push at a flow rate of 2 mL/min. Those with pain and edema but without coagulopathy and/or bleeding received a single vial of antivenom at H0. Additional doses of two vials were given in the event of persistence or resumption of bleeding at any the serial reassessment points listed earlier. IV catheters were flushed with 10 mL of sterile water or isotonic saline immediately following antivenom administration.
The group of 23 patients consisted of 15 envenomations by E. ocellatus, three by B. arietans, three by Naja nigricollis or N. katiensis, one dry bite of unknown origin and one peculiar dry bite or very mild envenomation from an unidentified rear-fanged colubrid or small elapid. With the exception of the two suspected dry bites, all patients were treated with 1–6 vials of Antivipmyn® Africa; there were no deaths and all patients recovered without major sequelae. There were 17 patients (74%) who showed clinical signs of abnormal local or systemic bleeding and abnormal WBCT (Table 3) meeting diagnostic criteria for the hemorrhagic syndrome.
The 17 patients with hemorrhagic envenomations included two B. arietans envenomations and 15 E. ocellatus envenomations. Most (11/17, 65%) showed anemia (hematocrit ≤35%) and nearly half of these patients (7/17, 41%) arrived in critical condition with a late-stage hemorrhagic syndrome (stages 4 or 5), unstable vital signs, major complications, and a high likelihood of imminent death unless urgent interventions were taken. The findings of the initial clinical assessment at H0 (abnormal local or systemic bleeding, anemia, blistering, necrosis, edema, etc.) supported the results of the initial diagnostic WBCT in all of our patients, and there were no false positive results at H0. The remaining 6/23 patients without coagulopathy or bleeding are detailed below (Table 4) and included four clinically significant envenomations that received antivenom treatment and two suspected dry bites that were managed symptomatically.
Discordance in WBCT results at 20 and 30 min was observed in 82% (14/17) of patients with bleeding disorders who received both tests, and are detailed in Table 3. The variation we observed between WBCT results at 20 versus 30 min-reading times was substantial, with an average time to resolution of coagulopathy following antivenom treatment of 6.7 h by WBCT20 and 13.1 h by WBCT30. Discrepancies were noted in at least one pair of serial WBCT readings and were identified specifically in four circumstances: upon initial assessment at H0 (Group 1, n = 3); upon initial normalization of hemostasis following antivenom therapy (Group 2, n = 7), upon secondary resumption of coagulopathy (Group 3a, n = 3); and upon restoration of hemostasis after a secondary resumption of coagulopathy (Group 3b, n = 2). There were three additional cases in which inconsistency was noted between results of the WBCT and the clinical assessment of the patient (Group 4). In these cases, both the WBCT20 and WBCT30 indicated restoration of hemostasis despite the presence of ongoing external and internal bleeding, which had markedly improved with antivenom therapy but persisted solely at the site of the gingival sulci for an additional 3 to 6 h before complete cessation of bleeding was observed. Discrepancy between results of WBCT readings was observed in only one of these three patients (case no. 5): WBCT20 was restored at H3, WBCT30 at H6, and bleeding resolved at H12. Tests were repeated using a new set of tubes in all three cases to confirm the peculiar results. Finally, in the remaining 3/17 patients (case no. 6, 8, and 18) normal coagulation was restored permanently and completely by H3 following a single dose of antivenom at H0.
Differences noted during initial assessment (Group 1) presented as variations in severity of coagulopathy (one gradation of WBCT scoring on the scale detailed in methods) rather than entirely contradictory results; two patients (case no. 4 and 15) exhibited a coagulopathy that improved by one grade between 20 and 30 min and the third patient (case no. 17) had a friable clot at 20 min that was completely incoagulable by 30. In six of seven cases, the two tests did not normalize simultaneously, WBCT20 was corrected earlier than WBCT30. Resumption of coagulopathy was observed in a total of seven patients with E. ocellatus envenomations and five of them exhibited discrepancies in WBCT results (Groups 3a and 3b; Table 5).
In two patients (cases no. 1 and 12, Fig. 3) there was a transient resumption of WBCT30 in the first 24 h that was inconsistent with the clinical picture of improvement observed at the time of the test, and there was no resumption of WBCT20 in either case. In the other five patients, a resumption of coagulopathy coincided with a resumption of envenomation signs and symptoms (gingival bleeding, internal bleeding, pain, edema, etc.) and therefore fit the diagnosis of a recurrent envenomation. In one of these patients (case no. 10), WBCT30 detected the recurrence of envenomation 21 h before it was detected by WBCT20 and coincided with the earliest symptoms of a renewed subarachnoid hemorrhage.
In the case of discrepancies upon final restoration of hemostasis after a secondary resumption of coagulopathy, WBCT20 was the first test to be corrected. In one of these cases, the improvement at WBCT20 corresponded with improvement in the recurrent envenomation. In the other case, the test remained abnormal at both reading times until WBCT20 briefly resolved at H144, which was inconsistent with the clinical picture of an active envenomation. WBCT20 became abnormal once again 24 h later at H168. Bleeding stopped and hematocrit stabilized ≤24 h after the final dose of antivenom was given at H168, but WBCT20 and WBCT30 remained abnormal until H240.
The ambient temperature in rooms where WBCT testing was performed was between 24 and 27 °C. Whether or not these temperature ranges influenced the coagulation time remains unknown. However, the consistency of temperatures during the study lends some uniformity to the results and the methods used here are consistent with those employed at rural healthcare facilities throughout Africa.
The frequency of coagulation disorders caused by the bite of Echis ocellatus (>75% of snakebite patients presenting to the hospital in Bembéréké) is corroborated by previously published observations in this region of Benin [3, 22,23,24,25]. The small number of patients is compensated by the homogeneity of measurements of the WBCT, all performed by the same clinician (JB) according to standard protocols, and of the species of snake responsible for the envenomation. In our series, the overall agreement between WBCT20 and WBCT30 was 100% in the absence of bleeding disorders or after they had resolved clinically. This suggests that the WBCT is likely to be a useful and clinically applicable test despite limitations and concerns over its incorrect application . The majority of discrepancies between WBCT results were observed after the initiation of antivenom therapy and during the period before recovery – a poorly understood area of interaction between the venom, the antivenom, and the unique characteristics of the patient. Differences between WBCT readings were most often seen upon initial resolution of coagulopathy or after secondary resumptions of coagulopathy, as determined by WBCT. The vast majority of discrepancies observed did not appear to result from a failure of the test because they did not occur when coagulopathy was either active (prior to treatment) or non-existent and, secondly, because the resumption in these cases was linked to the presence of clinical or hematological instability. Discrepancies seemed therefore to result from the action of the venom on blood coagulation, the efficacy of antivenom treatment, or the patient’s individual response to both the treatment and the envenomation.
In two patients, the blood did not coagulate at 20 min, but did 10 min later, suggesting either that a quantitative or qualitative deficiency of coagulation factor was responsible for the clotting delay or that there was an error in the collection method. One of these patients exhibited abnormal coagulation and persistent bleeding from the bitten limb 20 h after he was bitten twice by a large 2-m B. arietans. The dead snake in this case was taken to the hospital by the patient and identified by a herpetologist (JB). In contrast to the consumption coagulopathies seen in E. ocellatus envenomations, the patient showed a delayed coagulation with a very weak friable clot at 20 min, a markedly improved (but still friable) clot at 30 min, and a stable clot at 50 min that remained intact until disposal 24 h later. A second patient exhibited similarly delayed coagulation with a partial clot observed at 20 min and a stable clot at 30 min following a significantly less severe envenomation from a juvenile B. arietans that occurred at least 72 h earlier. She did not present with active bleeding, but reported that the wound started to bleed again 48 h prior to arrival and stopped several hours before she came to the hospital, which was supported by dried blood on and around the bite site in the absence of any apparent trauma.
Permanent restoration of hemostasis and cessation of bleeding in both patients was achieved at H3 following antivenom administration, suggesting that the findings may indeed have resulted from something related to the envenomation rather than the WBCT collection. Clinical coagulopathy due to envenomation by B. arietans is uncommon, but has been reported previously. Prolonged activated partial thromboplastin time and prothrombin time were reported in a patient who presented with systemic bleeding after B. arietans envenomation in Senegal . Spontaneous systemic bleeding, thrombocytopenia, and anemia have been reported in three patients from northern Nigeria despite normal WBCT20 results and normal levels of clotting factors and fibrin degradation products (FDPs) . WBCT30 was not reported in these cases.
In patients with coagulopathies due to E. ocellatus envenomation, we observed that any clots formed at 20 or 30 min during the first 24 h had often degraded again within 60 min of collection and returned to an incoagulable state prior to disposal. Further observation of blood samples collected from E. ocellatus envenomation patients in this study revealed the apparent formation and subsequent degradation of multiple clots in quick succession during the first several minutes after collection. Qualitative observation of the tubes during this time indicated a progressive reduction of this activity over time and by 15 min after collection the blood sample was approaching the state it would maintain upon evaluation at 20 min. When permanent resolution of hemostasis was achieved, stable clots generally persisted in the tube without any significant retraction and remained in this state 24 h later during disposal.
In six out of the seven patients from Group 2 with discrepancies in the initial resolution of coagulopathy, blood clotted within 20 min then returned to liquid form 10 min later. This situation suggests hyperfibrinolysis that could be due to either a factor present in the venom that was not neutralized by the antivenom, or a physiological factor present in the patient’s plasma. The presence of abnormal bleeding in the absence of coagulopathy reported in the three patients from Group 4 is therefore perplexing, but not entirely unprecedented. Authors of Nigerian cases suggest that bleeding may have resulted from a combination of direct action of the venom on the vascular endothelium in conjunction with a diminished platelet count . All three of our cases involved young patients with severe E. ocellatus envenomation, significant treatment delays, severe anemia, and late-stage bleeding syndromes. A complete blood count performed on the youngest patient found leukocyte count of 10.1 × 103/μL, erythrocyte count of 3.28 × 106/ μL, hemoglobin of 8.5 g/dL, and platelets of 229 × 103/μL. Whether the unusual bleeding resulted from the physiology of the patient, the venom, or the sampling method is impossible to determine with the available information.
Unfortunately, it has not been possible to continue hematological investigations in these patients because of the lack of appropriate laboratory facilities or more comprehensive testing capabilities on site. This issue, however, illustrates the importance of the WBCT in the rural healthcare centers where it is often the only means of detecting coagulopathy prior to the onset of detectable bleeding. Interestingly, 20% of patients bitten by E. ocellatus in northern Cameroon were diagnosed with primary fibrinolysis, confirmed by a significant increase FDPs without other abnormalities of blood coagulation parameters . Secondary fibrinolysis was observed in a further 40% of patients belonging to the same group, marked by significant increase of the FDPs and at least two other defective clotting factors (afibrinogenemia, thrombocytopenia or prolonged prothrombin time). There may have also been an association between both primary and secondary fibrinolysis in these patients.
Due to the considerable differences observed between the two reading times, clinically significant changes in hemostasis (initial resolution, secondary resumption and final resolution of coagulopathy) could be easily missed or misinterpreted if the WBCT was evaluated solely at 20 or 30 min. Based on the rapid formation and degradation of clots observed in the first 15 min after sample collection, it appears that the 20-min marker represents the earliest accurate reading time for WBCT evaluation. This period of formation and degradation of multiple clots during the first 15 or so minutes after collection represents another potential source of error in WBCT interpretation.
One author (JB) observed busy nurses and trained laboratory technicians in multiple healthcare centers as they set aside WBCT samples after collection and returned 5–10 min later to check for clot formation. If a clot was present, the test was reported as negative (no coagulopathy) and the sample was disposed of. This error was encountered on a number of occasions while conducting snakebite training for rural healthcare workers in both Benin and Kenya. The healthcare staff was under the impression that the formation of an apparently solid clot within 20 min constituted a negative WBCT (no coagulopathy). This could occur as a result of the large number of samples requiring processing and interpretation at a given time, or as a misunderstanding due to the fact that many of the standard coagulation tests are evaluated on the basis of time-to-coagulation rather than at a specific reading time.
Our observations during this study suggest that early WBCT interpretation, particularly in the first 15 min after collection, has a high likelihood of generating false negative results due to the repeated formation and degradation of transient clots that occurs during this time. This error may have contributed to the high number of false negatives and 40% sensitivity reported in a 2013 study on patients envenomed by Russell’s vipers . In that occasion, WBCT20 testing was carried out on the wards by clinical staff without training or supervision from study investigators .
A recent study by the same investigators found much higher sensitivity (82%) and specificity (98%) when the WBCT20 was standardized and performed exclusively by healthcare workers trained to conduct the test correctly . It is worth noting, however, that there were still 14 false positives and 14 false negatives recorded in the tested 79 patients with VICC . One study on diagnosis of green pit viper (Cryptelytops sp.) envenomations found a sensitivity of 85.7% and specificity of 95.8% for the WBCT20 when the fibrinogen level was less than 1.0 g/L . Research conducted in Papua New Guinea on reliability of the WBCT20 under different conditions reported a positive predictive value of 89.7%, negative predictive value of 93.5%, sensitivity of 92.9%, and specificity of 90.6% when fibrinogen concentrations were lower than 0.5 g/L in patients suffering from taipan (Oxyuranus scutellatus) snakebite . All of these results indicate the need for greater standardization to ensure that tests are read precisely at the 20th and/or 30th minutes instead of within that time period, as well as the need for further research into the influence of the reading time overall. They also suggest that when performed correctly, the WBCT remains an important tool for diagnosis of VICC when costly or more complex tests of coagulation are not available.
Another issue that must be further investigated is the effect of the tube material (glass type, plastic, new, used, wide, narrow etc.) on the WBCT results. The test should be performed in glass containers to facilitate activation of the intrinsic pathway by Hageman factor (factor XII), and it is widely accepted that plastic tubes should be avoided for this reason . A small 2015 study on the WBCT20 reported accurate results using soda-lime glass tubes and inaccurate results from both borosilicate glass and BD Vacutainer® glass tubes at some temperatures . While it is relatively easy to selectively avoid plastic tubes, many rural hospitals and clinics in Africa clean and reuse the same glass tubes until they are broken or scratched and discarded. Healthcare facilities in rural Africa and elsewhere in the developing world often accumulate donated and purchased laboratory glassware from a multitude of sources over the years. It would be unrealistic to assume that they will have the means or the time to accurately determine the chemical composition of this glassware with the limited resources available to them on a daily basis.
Even if it were possible for all facilities to purchase only soda-lime glass tubes for these tests, the abundance of counterfeit medical supplies in West Africa nullifies the value of such an approach. We observed this issue firsthand on numerous occasions including fake antivenom composed of starches instead of proteins, new boxes of counterfeit Red-Top BD Vacutainer® tubes that were contaminated with a chemical residue, and even a shipment of grounded electrical cords missing all of the copper grounding wire except for an inch on either end to give the illusion of a genuine product. Following initial treatment in busy hospitals throughout sub-Saharan Africa, it is not uncommon for episodic surveillance of coagulation by WBCT to cease once a patient has demonstrated resolution of the hemorrhagic syndrome by H6, H12, H24, or H48 based on the assumption that permanent resolution has been achieved. The majority of resumptions we observed occurred 24 to 96 h after initial treatment at H0 and would not have been detected in most cases unless a consistent regimen of WBCT evaluation was maintained throughout hospitalization or if the coagulopathy was allowed to develop undetected until significant internal hemorrhage or anemia was identified symptomatically and provoked further WBCT testing.
It is possible that a nexus exists between the half-life of the antivenom, the decrease in local edema, and the recurrence of an envenomation. Venom reservoirs could theoretically become trapped in tight tissue compartments such as the tibialis. The swelling often takes 48 to 72 h before beginning to decrease, at which point the half-life of the F(ab)2 immunoglobulins has been exceeded. If the venom trapped in the reservoir was able to escape from the tissue compartment during this time, it could overwhelm the amount of circulating antivenom that remains and produce the recurrent envenomations observed in these cases.
The clinical significance of these findings is multifaceted. In the context of the current shortage of effective antivenom for snakebite in sub-Saharan Africa, any improvements in the efficiency of antivenom usage can save additional lives by conserving antivenom for cases in which it is required and also prevents considerable financial burden for the patient. These findings may have implications for evaluating the efficacy of new antivenoms and identifying when neutralizing capacity differs based on the composition of the venom .
Many prospective antivenoms for sub-Saharan Africa have been assessed using only WBCT20 or WBCT30 evaluation, but not both. If the trends observed in this study are accurate, then we would expect antivenoms assessed at 20 min to demonstrate earlier resolution of coagulopathy and later secondary resumptions of coagulopathy (or fewer resumptions overall, if the resumptions do not occur until after WBCT testing has ceased). Antivenoms assessed at 30 min would appear by comparison to be significantly less effective with longer time to restoration of normal coagulation states and greater incidence of secondary resumptions of coagulopathy. Future studies on this subject may benefit from strictly adhering to a standardized reading time (20 min, 30 min, or both) and a standardized timeline for sequential readings (both frequency and duration of WBCT testing, for example at H3, H6, H12, H24, H48, H72, and so on until the half-life of circulating antivenom has been exceeded by 24 to 48 h without a resumption of symptoms or coagulopathy).
The findings of this study may also allow for improvements in the efficiency of snakebite treatment using existing antivenoms. Had we followed the treatment protocol used in this study in conjunction with the results of WBCT30 alone, more antivenom would have been administered due to the higher number of persistent coagulopathies and transient resumptions observed. It is unknown whether the additional treatment would have benefited any of these patients, but in a small number of patients with complicated internal hemorrhage and lengthy treatment delay, the coagulopathies persisted regardless of the amount of antivenom administered and may have resulted from the physiology of the patient rather than the action of the antivenom.
Interestingly, there was a marked improvement in signs and symptoms within 24 h of the additional antivenom doses in these patients despite the persistence of coagulopathy for several more days. This may reflect an inertia in the restoration of completed depleted clotting factors in some patients. There were some instances in which WBCT30 was the first test to detect a clinically significant resumption of symptomatic coagulopathy whereas WBCT20 remained within normal range considerably longer. Interpreting the results of the test in the context of the patient is paramount. For example, WBCT testing of a patient reporting an onset of new symptoms several days after treatment may help determine whether the change in condition is due to an immune response to the antivenom or the action of some quantity of venom that is actively circulating in the bloodstream. Whether or not these trends are applicable in a broader context warrants further, large scale systematic evaluation. Until programmatic attention is given to the problem of snakebite, potentially useful tools to combat the resulting morbidity and mortality will remain under evaluated and controversial.
There are few tests as readily available and informative to the clinician treating snakebites as the WBCT. It is not perfect, but it does provide a practical and functional solution where none exists. We found no indications that either reading time was superior overall. Each test appeared more or less capable of detecting different events under different circumstances than its counterpart, and neither test on its own provided an alternative to basic clinical medicine and a sound physical examination. Discrepancies in WBCT results should be interpreted together in the context of the overall clinical picture at the time of assessment.
Expanding interpretation of the WBCT to include evaluation at both 20 and 30 min may allow for a reduction in the number of false negatives or false positives during initial assessment as well as greater detection of recurrent envenomation later in the course of care. If these differences remain consistent in larger studies, it could provide a simple way to increase the tools available to medical providers for the assessment, diagnosis, treatment, and extended management of snakebite patients in sub-Saharan Africa. Though further study is needed to investigate the extent of differences between the two methods of WBCT testing, by examining both we gained a more complete view of the improvement, deterioration, and response to antivenom treatment of our patients, especially in the setting of Echis ocellatus envenomation. Further studies exploring the reading time and involving more complete hematological analyses are planned to confirm and explain these results.
Antivipmyn® Africa (Bioclon, Mexico) polyvalent antivenom
Fibrin degradation products
- H0 :
Hour 0, initial assessment upon arrival at the hospital
- Ha :
Number of hours since H0
Venom-induced consumption coagulopathy
Whole blood clotting test
- WBCT20 ≠ WBCT30:
Discrepancies between results of WBCT20 and WBCT30
Whole blood clotting test with a reading time of 20 min
Whole blood clotting test with a reading time of 30 min
Chippaux JP. Snakebite envenomation turns again into a neglected tropical disease! J Venom Anim Toxins incl Trop Dis. 2017;23:38. https://doi.org/10.1186/s40409-017-0127-6.
Chippaux JP, Akaffou MH, Allali BK, Dosso M, Massougbodji A, Barraviera B. The 6th international conference on envenomation by snakebites and scorpion stings in Africa: a crucial step for the management of envenomation. J Venom Anim Toxins incl Trop Dis. 2016;22:11. https://doi.org/10.1186/s40409-016-0062-y.
Chippaux JP, Massougbodji A, Stock RP, Alagon A. Investigators of African Antivipmyn in Benin. Clinical trial of an F(ab’)2 polyvalent equine antivenom for African snake bites in Benin. Am J Trop Med Hyg. 2007;77(3):538–46.
Pongpit J, Limpawittayakul P, Juntiang J, Akkawat B, Rojnuckarin P. The role of prothrombin time (PT) in evaluating green pit viper (Cryptelytrops sp) bitten patients. Trans R Soc Trop Med Hyg. 2012;106(7):415–8.
Gaus DP, Herrera DF, Troya CJ, Guevara AH. Management of snakebite and systemic envenomation in rural Ecuador using the 20-minute whole blood clotting test. Wilderness Environ Med. 2013;24(4):345–50.
Punguyire D, Iserson KV, Stolz U, Apanga S. Bedside whole-blood clotting times: validity after snakebites. J Emerg Med. 2013;44(3):663–7.
Warrell DA, Davidson NM, Greenwood BM, Ormerod LD, Pope HM, Watkins BJ, et al. Poisoning by bites of the saw-scaled or carpet viper (Echis carinatus) in Nigeria. Q J Med. 1977;46(181):33–62.
Sano-Martins IS, Fan HW, Castro SC, Tomy SC, Franca FO, Jorge MT, et al. Reliability of the simple 20 minute whole blood clotting test (WBCT20) as an indicator of low plasma fibrinogen concentration in patients envenomed by Bothrops snakes. Toxicon. 1994;32(9):1045–50.
Meyer WP, Habib AG, Onayade AA, Yakubu A, Smith DC, Nasidi A, et al. First clinical experiences with a new ovine Fab Echis ocellatus snake bite antivenom in Nigeria: randomized comparative trial with Institute Pasteur Serum (Ipser) Africa antivenom. Am J Trop Med Hyg. 1997;56(3):291–300.
Chippaux JP, Amadi-Eddine S, Fagot P. Diagnosis and monitoring of hemorrhage due to viper envenomation in the African savanna. Bull Soc Pathol Exot. 1999;92(2):109–13. [Article in French]
Ratnayake I, Shihana F, Dissanayake DM, Buckley NA, Maduwage K, Isbister GK. Performance of the 20-minute whole blood clotting test in detecting venom induced consumption coagulopathy from Russell’s viper (Daboia russelii) bites. Thromb Haemost. 2017;117(3):500–7.
Rojnuckarin P, Mahasandana S, Intragumthornchai T, Sutcharitchan P, Swasdikul D. Prognostic factors of green pit viper bites. Am J Trop Med Hyg. 1998;58(1):22–5.
Chippaux JP, Lang J, Eddine SA, Fagot P, Rage V, Peyrieux JC, Le Mener V. Clinical safety of a polyvalent F(ab’)2 equine antivenom in 223 African snake envenomations: a field trial in Cameroon. Trans R Soc Trop Med Hyg. 1998;92(6):657–62. VAO (Venin Afrique de l’Ouest) Investigators
Abubakar IS, Abubakar SB, Habib AG, Nasidi A, Durfa N, Yusuf PO, et al. Randomised controlled double-blind non-inferiority trial of two antivenoms for saw-scaled or carpet viper (Echis ocellatus) envenoming in Nigeria. PLoS Negl Trop Dis. 2010;4(7):e767.
Stone R, Seymour J, Marshall O. Plastic containers and the whole-blood clotting test: glass remains the best option. Trans R Soc Trop Med Hyg. 2006;100(12):1168–72.
Isbister GK, Maduwage K, Shahmy S, Mohamed F, Abeysinghe C, Karunathilake H, et al. Diagnostic 20-min whole blood clotting test in Russell’s viper envenoming delays antivenom administration. QJM. 2013;106(10):925–32.
Paiva OK, Bande B, Power R, Williams DJ. Clinical evaluation of the 20 Minute Whole Blood Clotting Test (20WBCT) and reliability at different temperatures and types of glassware. Paper presented at the 18th World Congress of the International Society on Toxinology, Oxford University, Oxford; 2015.
Baker RB, Summer SS, Lawrence M, Shova A, McGraw CA, Khoury J. Determining optimal waste volume from an intravenous catheter. J Infus Nurs. 2013;36(2):92–6.
Zlotowski SJ, Kupas DF, Wood GC. Comparison of laboratory values obtained by means of routine venipuncture versus peripheral intravenous catheter after a normal saline solution bolus. Ann Emerg Med. 2001;38(5):497–504.
Zengin N, Enç N. Comparison of two blood sampling methods in anticoagulation therapy: venipuncture and peripheral venous catheter. J Clin Nurs. 2008;17(3):386–93.
Cicolini G, Simonetti V, Di Nicola M, Palma E. Comparison of blood samples values by direct venipuncture and central venous catheters with 5 or 10 ml wasted blood. J Clin Nurs. 2012;21(1–2):281–4.
Chippaux JP, Baldé MC, Sessinou É, Yéro Boiro M, Massougbodji A. Evaluation of a new polyvalent antivenom against snakebite envenomation (Inoserp® Panafricain) in two different epidemiological settings: Northern Benin and Maritime Guinea. Med Sante Trop. 2015;25(1):56–64. [Article in French]
Fourn L, Adè G, Fayomi EB, Zohoun T. Epidemiological aspects of snakebites in Benin. Bull Soc Pathol Exot. 2005;98(4):291–2. [Article in French]
Chippaux JP. Snake bite epidemiology in Benin. Bull Soc Pathol Exot. 2002;95(3):172–4. [Article in French]
Massougbodji M, Chobli M, Assouto P, Lokossou T, Sanoussi H, Sossou A, et al. Geoclimatology and severity of snake bite envenomations in Benin. Bull Soc Pathol Exot. 2002;95(3):175–7. [Article in French]
Le Dantec P, Hervé Y, Niang B, Chippaux JP, Bellefleur JP, Boulesteix G, et al. Abstract envenomation by the African puff adder (Bitis arietans): value of intracompartmental pressure measurement. Med Trop (Mars). 2004;64(2):187–91. [Article in French]
Warrell DA, Ormerod LD, Davidson NM. Bites by puff-adder (Bitis arietans) in Nigeria, and value of antivenom. Br Med J. 1975;4(5998):697–700.
Chippaux JP, Williams V, White J. Snake venom variability: methods of study, results and interpretation. Toxicon. 1991;29(11):1279–303.
The input and expertise of Dr. Roberto Stock was essential in the success of this study, and without his earlier work on Antivipmyn® this research would not have been possible. Special thanks are due to Dr. Kate Jackson of Whitman College for making this research possible and for the guidance and unwavering support she provided throughout the process of drafting this article. The tireless work of the physicians, nurses, laboratory personnel and other staff at the Hôpital Evangelique Bembèrèkè is to be commended and without their skill and generous hosting for the onsite study coordinator the work could not have been accomplished. We owe an extreme debt of gratitude to the patients who participated in this study. The clinical skill, dedication, and kindness of Dr. Mathilde Petit, Dr. Lucie Mayer, Dr. Cardinal Akpakpa and Dr. Pierre Mayer greatly contributed to the success of the field study while in Bembèrèkè. We also recognize and greatly appreciate the contributions of Sanda Ashe and the Bio-Ken Snake Farm for sharing their expertise and the wealth of knowledge they have amassed in the field of snakebite treatment during this project.
Availability of data and materials
All relevant data generated or analyzed during this study is included in this published article.
Ethics approval and consent to participate
This study is the continuation of the clinical trial of Antivipmyn Africa in northern Benin, which was cleared by the Comité d’Ethique de la Faculté des Sciences de la Santé de l’Université d’Abomey Calavi du Bénin (Ethics Committee of the Faculty of Health Sciences of the University of Abomey-Calavi, Benin) in June 2005, renewed in June 2013 (14/06/2013/EC/FSS/UAC).
Consent for publication
Informed consent for publication of this study and any accompanying images was obtained from all participating patients or a parent or legal guardian when a child was involved.
The authors declare that they have no competing interests.
Springer Nature remains neutral with regard to jurisdictional claims in published maps and institutional affiliations.
About this article
- Whole blood clotting test
- Venom-induced consumption coagulopathy
- Carpet viper
- Saw-scaled viper